wongaBlog
7May/103

Election night 2010

This might be incoherent, as I was up until half 7 this morning and have only slept fitfully since, but it's worth a try. With one massive caveat, election night 2010 was almost quite fun. As I settled in at 22:00 last night, I was dreading the thought of a  Tory majority. So the all-to-play-for exit poll was a nice surprise. The BBC election team of course then spent hours telling me it was probably wrong, and when the first few seats saw a huge Conservative swing I was close to calling it a night. Then it all started to go haywire, with small swings in Tory easy targets, Wales and Scotland comprehensively rejecting anything blue, and confusion generally setting in. I really wanted to stay up for a few particular results, and if I could also witness the Tories not win, all the better. And, of course, the exit poll turned out to be almost spot on, even if nobody's quite sure how.

I can't pretend to be thrilled with the result, but it could be far, far worse. I didn't want a Tory rout - a large Conservative government with a mandate to do whatever they want is a very unpleasant thought. But I didn't mind Labour getting a bit chastened, either - they could do with an ideological rethink in a few areas, and I think this may happen once Gordon Brown goes, which he presumably will. But I was hoping this would happen by a swing to the Lib Dems, and their lack of progress is a real shame. Obviously they have an important role over the next few days, and hopefully they'll finally manage to extract electoral reform from whichever party ends up ruling (and this may save Nick Clegg). That said, I just can't imagine a Lib-Lab Lib-Con coalition working for long. Lib-Lab, maybe; Lib-Con - they're just too different: the Lib Dems are, you know, nice.

However, while yesterday I'd have been disappointed at the possibility of another general election, that all changed at 05:30 when Evan Harris lost by 176 votes to a Christian candidate. That is bloody not ok. Evan Harris was the shining light of science and reason in the House of Commons. In the past decade he's repealed the blasphemy laws; led the charge on blocking religious hatred laws; campaigned fiercely for libel reform, stem cell research, and assisted dying legislation; spoken against admissions and employment discrimination by faith schools; held back anti-abortion amendments, and - in the last few days of the last parliament - unleashed hell upon the government for ramming through the Digital Economy Act. For all these things the religious lobby hate him and launched a huge media slur campaign - and they're crowing today. This has to be fixed. This year I offered to help his campaign as a photographer, but this wasn't something they needed, and for whatever reason I didn't get involved further, despite receiving a general email asking for help with distributing leaflets etc.. I feel pretty bad about this. Next time I'll do whatever they want, and hopefully half of the skeptical community on Twitter will be there too.

Staying up through the night with just Twitter for company is great. There's a nice sense of a shared experience, with everyone who's still awake at 4am suffering a bit and keeping each other going. And when there's bad news it's cathartic to join in with the general fury, and then everyone yells at the Tories. So big thanks to my witching hour chums.

2Nov/090

Quotes of the day

Both from Ben Goldacre's latest:

“I am talking about a long-standing discipline—an art and a science—that has been with us since ancient Egyptian, Roman, Babylonian and Assyrian times. It is part of the Chinese, Muslim and Hindu cultures… Criticism is deeply offensive to those cultures,” says Tredinnnick: “and I have a Muslim college in my constituency.”

That's Conservative MP David Tredinnick defending his view that the moon is evil. To cleanse:

The honourable Member for Braintree cited evidence from The Sun, so I want to refer to a recent edition of the British Medical Journal.

That's Evan Harris, Lib Dem MP for Oxford West & Abingdon (from a different debate).

8Jan/080

Repeal the Blasphemy Law, starting this Wednesday

This Wednesday Dr Evan Harris MP will propose an amendment to the Criminal Justice and Immigration Bill that abolishes the offences of blasphemy and blasphemous libel. It's about time.

Right now, if Blue Peter named their teddy bear Jesus, Gethin Jones could get sent to prison. Muhammed? Free speech. Buddah? Bulletproof. But Jesus gets special treatment, as the blasphemy laws cover Christian belief only. Isn't this alone reason enough for a repeal?

There's a danger that we might head the other way at some point. Rather than repeal the law, why not add cover for Islam? And, while we're at it, jews and hindus would like their religion protected too. Oooh, and Jehovah's Witnesses. The Scientologists would also like a piece of the action, please, and they have an army of lawyers to ensure it happens. This clearly wouldn't work. Isn't a level playing field the only practical, as well as moral, solution?

This is no secular attack on religion. The legal system works on the basis of individual rights, yet this law protects opinions, not people. A law forbidding criticism of atheism would be just as stupid. If anybody doesn't like what we see on television, they get to say so without fear of being locked up. This is simply the decent way to behave.

It's true that there hasn't been a blasphemy prosecution in a long time. But it's a law, and not something that should be taken lightly. Christian Voice tried to attack the BBC using the blasphemy law. The BBC fought back, but small theatres, publishers and media outlets don't have this luxury. It's reasonable to be intimidated when the law says you're not allowed to criticise certain beliefs.

It's archaic and ridiculous, and no part of a modern democracy. The Law Commission recommended its repeal back in 1985, and even the Church of England no longer opposes its abolition. Let's ditch it.

I've written to my MP. It's easy to do, just go to http://www.theyworkforyou.com/mp and enter your postcode - you'll be sent to a page where you can directly email your representative in parliament. Only takes two minutes - so why not?